Skip to content

EU Court Rules US Data Protection Adequate, but Warns of Future Review

The EU's top court upholds the US's data protection standards. However, it warns that the EU will closely monitor US laws to ensure the equivalence of data protection.

In the picture there is a data card connected to a laptop.
In the picture there is a data card connected to a laptop.

EU Court Rules US Data Protection Adequate, but Warns of Future Review

The European Union's highest court has ruled that the US provides an adequate level of protection for personal data transferred from the EU. The European Court of Justice (ECJ) dismissed a Frenchman's lawsuit challenging the new framework for data transfers between the EU and the US.

The ECJ ruled that the 'Data Protection Review Court' (DPRC) in the US, which oversees the mass collection of personal data, is independent. The court noted several guarantees and conditions that ensure the independence of DPRC members and their operations.

The plaintiff argued that the DPRC was not independent and that the US intelligence agencies' data collection practices were illegal. However, the court found no violation of the requirements of previous rulings and confirmed that the level of legal protection in the US is equivalent to that guaranteed by EU law.

The European Commission can monitor the decision and respond to changes in US law. If the US government weakens its privacy safeguards, the EU may suspend or invalidate adequacy decisions allowing such data flows, as the ECJ requires that transferred personal data receive protection equivalent to EU standards.

The ECJ's ruling is a significant development in transatlantic data transfers. It ensures that personal data transferred from the EU to the US receives adequate protection, but the EU will closely monitor US data protection laws to maintain this equivalence.

Read also:

Latest