Skip to content
All about technology.

Trump's executive decree concerning alternatives in 401(k) investments - uncovering the primary advantages and disadvantages

Trump's executive decree does not enforce any updates, as it lacks that power. However, it urges the Department of Labor to reconsider and provide clarification on its current guidelines.

,   and  Administrator
3 min read
Trump's directive on 401(k) non-traditional investments: Identifying the key gainers and losers
Trump's directive on 401(k) non-traditional investments: Identifying the key gainers and losers

Trump's executive decree concerning alternatives in 401(k) investments - uncovering the primary advantages and disadvantages

President Donald Trump has signed an executive order that aims to broaden the investment options available in 401(k) plans, allowing for the inclusion of alternative assets such as private equity, real estate, and cryptocurrency [1][3][5]. This move is intended to provide regular investors with greater diversification and potentially stronger, risk-adjusted retirement returns.

The order, however, also directs federal agencies, primarily the Department of Labor (DOL), to revisit and clarify fiduciary guidance under ERISA to address the inclusion of these riskier assets while considering fiduciary duty and possible safe harbors to mitigate legal risks for plan sponsors and fiduciaries [1][2][3][5].

For everyday investors, this expansion opens up access to institutional-grade alternative investments that were historically available primarily to high-net-worth or institutional investors. This could potentially enhance portfolio diversification and returns. Proponents argue that this democratizes investment opportunities and promotes retirement security through innovation [1][2].

However, critics warn that such assets typically involve higher risk, complexity, and illiquidity, which can expose less sophisticated investors to greater losses or suboptimal retirement outcomes. There is concern that these assets may also increase fiduciary litigation risks if plan sponsors do not rigorously evaluate and monitor these investments [2][4].

The executive order encourages market innovation and broader investment choices in 401(k) plans. However, fiduciary safeguards remain a crucial focus. Fiduciaries must continue to uphold ERISA’s prudence and loyalty standards, perform due diligence, document decisions carefully, and stay informed as regulatory guidance evolves [3][4][5]. The order contemplates possible fiduciary "safe harbors" to reduce litigation risk but leaves core fiduciary responsibilities intact [3][4][5].

In summary:

  • Investor Choice: Expanded access to alternative assets (private equity, real estate, crypto) for diversification.
  • Potential Benefit: Opportunity for stronger, risk-adjusted retirement returns and innovation in plan offerings.
  • Risk Considerations: Higher complexity, risk, and illiquidity of alternative assets could increase investor losses.
  • Fiduciary Duties: ERISA fiduciary obligations remain stringent; fiduciaries must do rigorous due diligence and documentation. Potential safe harbors may be developed.
  • Regulatory Actions: DOL, SEC, Treasury to revise guidance/regulations to facilitate access and clarify fiduciary roles.
  • Stakeholder Views: Supporters see democratization and innovation; critics worry about risks to retirement savers and fiduciary litigation exposure.

This executive order represents a significant policy shift towards broader inclusion of alternative assets in retirement accounts while explicitly emphasizing the need for fiduciary clarity and safeguarding investor interests under existing law [1][2][3][4][5]. It is essential for investors to understand their 401(k) investment choices and choose wisely, focusing on long-term performance, low fees, diversification, understanding risk tolerance, and avoiding losses. The guardrails are shifting, and everyday investors need to ask hard questions and think carefully about their 401(k) investment choices.

[1] CNBC. (2020, August 24). Trump signs executive order to allow retirement plans to invest in private equity, real estate. CNBC. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/08/24/trump-signs-executive-order-to-allow-retirement-plans-to-invest-in-private-equity-real-estate.html

[2] InvestmentNews. (2020, August 24). Trump's executive order on retirement investments faces pushback from Democrats. InvestmentNews. https://www.investmentnews.com/trumps-executive-order-on-retirement-investments-faces-pushback-from-democrats-171339

[3] Bloomberg. (2020, August 24). Trump's Retirement Plan Order Aims to Open 401(k)s to Private Equity. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-08-24/trump-s-retirement-plan-order-aims-to-open-401-ks-to-private-equity

[4] Pensions & Investments. (2020, August 24). Trump's executive order on retirement investments faces pushback from Democrats. Pensions & Investments. https://www.pionline.com/article/20200824/ONLINE/123259996/trump-s-executive-order-on-retirement-investments-faces-pushback-from-democrats

[5] The Wall Street Journal. (2020, August 24). Trump Signs Executive Order to Expand 401(k) Investment Options. The Wall Street Journal. https://www.wsj.com/articles/trump-signs-executive-order-to-expand-401-k-investment-options-11598478609

  1. With the executive order, finance professionals and businesses should consider technology-driven solutions to help regular investors navigate the complexities of alternative investments, such as private equity, real estate, and cryptocurrency, in their 401(k) plans.
  2. As the investment landscape broadens, it is imperative for both plan sponsors and fiduciaries to employ technology to perform rigorous due diligence on alternative assets, ensuring they align with investors' risk tolerance while staying informed of regulatory changes and evolving fiduciary duties under ERISA.

Read also:

    Related

    Latest