Will regulatory oversight pose a threat to the sustainability of Decentralized Finance (DeFi)?
Following the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s (SEC) roundtable titled "DeFi and the American Spirit" held on June 9, 2025, the expected regulatory framework for decentralized finance (DeFi) in the U.S. is focused on enhancing investor protection, ensuring market integrity, and fostering innovation under the SEC’s existing mandate.
The SEC, led by Commissioner Hester Peirce and President Paul Atkins, emphasizes promoting fair, orderly, and efficient markets while trying to integrate DeFi within regulatory boundaries suited for consumer safety and capital formation.
Key aspects of the expected approach include:
- Regulatory clarity and engagement: The SEC signals its intent to engage with stakeholders to clarify how existing securities laws apply to DeFi protocols and platforms.
- Investor protection: Measures to safeguard retail investors from risks inherent in DeFi, such as fraud, market manipulation, and lack of transparency, will be prioritized.
- Technology-neutral application: The SEC appears focused on applying regulatory principles consistently regardless of technology, indicating DeFi projects may be regulated similarly to traditional finance if they perform comparable functions.
- Coordination with other agencies: The roundtable and subsequent discussions suggest coordination efforts between the SEC, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), and other regulatory bodies to create a cohesive regulatory landscape.
- Ongoing dialogue and research: The SEC’s Crypto Task Force continues to solicit public input and participant engagement to shape effective policies while balancing innovation and market integrity.
No detailed new rulemaking has been publicly disclosed immediately following the roundtable, but the event marks a significant step in the SEC’s ongoing efforts to craft a regulatory framework tailored to the unique challenges and opportunities DeFi presents.
The main objective is to determine if DeFi can be regulated without stifling its innovative spirit. Overly strict regulations may discourage the development of new DeFi platforms, limit participation, and hinder blockchain technology adoption. On the other hand, the lack of control and supervision in DeFi may facilitate abuses or illicit activities.
The roundtable includes crypto experts, academics, industry representatives, and regulatory figures. A legal framework could differentiate between custodial and non-custodial DeFi platforms, allowing the latter to operate with greater freedom. Regulation could foster geographical innovation, providing a safer and more structured environment for developers and users.
DeFi is opening the doors to greater financial autonomy and democratizing access to money. Establishing a regulatory framework is essential to prevent potential abuses and protect investors. Past regulatory investigations, such as those involving Uniswap, suggest that open dialogue and well-oriented regulation can coexist with the sector’s fundamental values.
In conclusion, the expected U.S. regulatory framework post-June 9 roundtable will likely involve applying existing securities laws to DeFi, enhancing investor safeguards, and fostering cooperation between federal agencies while maintaining vigilance toward technological innovation in financial markets.
- Commissioner Hester Peirce and President Paul Atkins, leading the SEC, aim to integrate decentralized finance (DeFi) within existing regulatory boundaries, emphasizing technology-neutral application, fostering innovation, and promoting fair, orderly, and efficient markets in finance and investing, enabled by blockchain technology.
- The anticipated regulatory framework will prioritize investor protection by safeguarding retail investors from risks in DeFi, such as fraud, market manipulation, and lack of transparency, while encouraging regulatory clarity and engagement, coordination with other agencies, and ongoing dialogue and research to shape effective policies, thereby preventing potential abuses and protecting investors in the DeFi sector.
%3F){kind=link}